Analysis of the UN Report by Reem Alsalem titled Sex-Based Violence Against Women and Girls: New Frontiers and Emerging Issues

Purpose of the Report

The report examines new and evolving forms of sex-based violence against women and girls that remain underrecognized. It reaffirms the biological reality of sex as central to understanding female oppression and urges States to protect women’s sex-based rights, especially amid rising gender identity ideologies.

Key Issues Identified

  1. Erasure of Sex in Law and Policy
    • Women are being redefined based on gender identity, undermining sex-based protections.
    • Neutral language like “people who menstruate” replaces terms like “women”, erasing their legal identity.
  2. Loss of Sex-Based Data
    • The shift toward gender identity in data collection undermines the ability to track violence against women and develop targeted policies.
    • Healthcare outcomes for women are especially impacted by this data gap.
  3. Reinforcement of Sexist Stereotypes
    • Gender identity frameworks often rely on regressive stereotypes (e.g., “feminine dress” = woman).
    • This harms girls, especially those with autism or gender dysphoria, by pushing them toward irreversible medical interventions.
  4. Suppression of Women’s Free Speech
    • Women face intimidation, job loss, online abuse, and even violence for speaking out on biological sex and women’s rights.
    • Gender-critical feminists are often mislabelled as hateful or transphobic.
  5. Denial of Single-Sex Spaces
    • Prisons, shelters, hospitals, and other institutions are increasingly removing female-only spaces, putting women at risk.
    • Women in prisons are being forced to share spaces with violent male offenders who self-identify as women.
  6. Emerging Forms of Violence
    • Consequential suicide (linked to abuse by male partners)
    • “Femi-genocide” (e.g., systemic violence against Palestinian and Afghan women)
    • Sex-selective abortion and infanticide (especially in parts of Asia)
    • Digital sexual violence (deepfakes, revenge porn, and AI-generated abuse targeting girls and women)

International Legal Context

  • Reaffirms obligations under:
    • CEDAW (Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women)
    • CRC (Convention on the Rights of the Child)
    • ICCPR and other international human rights treaties
  • Emphasizes that gender identity should not override the legal category of sex for women’s protection.

Key Recommendations

  1. Protect Sex-Based Rights
    • Use terms like “woman” and “girl” strictly for biological females in law.
    • Reinstate single-sex spaces and services where necessary.
  2. Reject Irreversible Medical Transition for Minors
    • Ban puberty blockers and surgeries for children.
    • Offer comprehensive assessments and alternative support.
  3. Combat Sexist Stereotypes
    • Regulate pornography and media.
    • Launch education campaigns promoting respectful masculinity.
  4. Criminalize Femicide and Collect Sex-Based Data
    • Establish observatories to track femicide.
    • Ensure data on violence is disaggregated by biological sex.
  5. Recognize Reproductive Violence as Genocidal
    • Hold states accountable where reproductive abuse is used to control or erase populations (e.g., Gaza, Myanmar, Sudan).

Conclusion

The Special Rapporteur calls for urgent action to re-centre biological sex in law and policy, defend free expression for women, and confront new forms of violence arising from both digital abuse and identity-based policies that erase female realities.

READ THE REPORT HERE:

https://www.ohchr.org/en/documents/thematic-reports/ahrc5947-sex-based-violence-against-women-and-girls-new-frontiers-and

LISTEN HERE:

“You can not protect what you can not define” Reem Alsalem